I found this via Google maps while looking for a place to eat. I would not have found it otherwise. It is a hole in the wall place. No signage of any kind except a small wooden sign out on the sidewalk with the restaurant name. If you drove by it you wouldn’t even blink twice.
It is a tight little spot, rectangular with a bar on one side with stools and booths along the edge. Probably seats about 30 comfortably.
Wine list is two and a half pages long and the beer menu is one side of an index card. The bar has three taps but one was out of service when we went. They had a really good blonde ale from Sünner brewery and the Richmond “#4″ Brown Ale.
The wooden booths force you to sit upright. They are not comfortable. Warped painted ceiling tiles look weathered. There’s big colorful artwork around all the walls and the paintings just rest on molding on the wall. The lights are all covered with paper so it gives the place a warm atmosphere.
I ordered an apple and onion soup which was unlike anything I’ve had before. It was delicious. My friend and I scarfed down the entire bowl very quickly.
Next up was an appetizer with blue fish, goat cheese, capers all on a crunchy piece of toast. Looking at it gave me bad vibes, but once I tasted one – the plate was empty.
The bread plate (that’s brought out as a standard appetizer) was kind of a let down. Bread wasn’t toasted. There was no butter. The bread was fresh, but boring.
The restaurant was empty but it took 30 minutes to get our main course. I was a bit upset by this point, but when we dug in I realized it was worth the wait.
I ordered the Greek Pork. It literally melted in my mouth. I could break the meat apart with my tongue. The tangy yogurt, the layer of pepper and spices on the outside of the meat, the soft pieces of potato, the feta. And kale. I ate kale for the first time without throwing up. It was amazing.
My friend ordered the Roasted Salmon. It is a deceptively simple dish. The sweet potato kind of masks the fish taste when the food first enters your mouth. After a few seconds the fish flavor “pops.” It’s an interesting combination that tastes really good.
If you go, be sure to go to the bathroom. You need to experience the same Twilight Zone shit I went through.
The prices are fair; I felt like I got my money’s worth. I give Café Rustica a 4 out of 5.